How Best To Enslave Us?

Political scientists have long pondered the pre-conditions that lead to totalitarian rule, but I would argue that 20th century literature does a far better job of describing a world where humans are induced or compelled to surrender their freedoms for a bit of comfort, an illusion of security, a fantasy of belonging, or a taste of carnal pleasure. History has taught us that, sad to say, we rarely succeed at self-rule, and the predominance of monarchies, oligarchies, theocracies, and dictatorships (sometimes all four at once) across the span of human civilization would seem to compel us to consider how and why we continue to slide into forms of governance where we have no voice in making the rules.

Those authors who have most vividly and chillingly imagined worlds where the few rule the many—Ray Bradbury, George Orwell, and Aldous Huxley—all seem to agree that ignorance is the path to tyranny. In Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 (where books are routinely burned by “firemen” employed by the government), Orwell’s 1984 (where the past is continually altered to fit the propaganda  of the present), and Huxley’s Brave New World (where the populace is taught that “History is bunk”), all but the favored few at the very top of the societal pyramid understand how conformity is enforced and critical thinking officially discouraged; in Brave New World, in fact, vast swathes of the population are genetically altered to reduce intelligence and conditioned to placidly accept the menial work assigned to them.

Should we see a parallel today when we look at our generally dismal public schools, which spend hundreds upon hundreds of billions of dollars every year to somehow produce graduates who know little (if that), are shockingly ignorant of our complex world and its rich history, and are often suited for only the most dully repetitive employment—if they are employable at all?

Perhaps because stupidity is incredibly dismal (although in all three novels the masses are kept breathlessly distracted with mindless daily entertainments), totalitarianism requires drugs to keep the commoners content. The most chilling parallel with our modern world is found in Brave New World, where a readily available drug called Soma, which functions as a combination of an anti-depressant and tranquilizer, is dispensed to everyone from the moronic workers to the carefree elite to keep their moods flatlined and their yearnings to question the dysfunctional status quo repressed.

Our incredibly doped-up nation today—in which so many seem incapable of functioning without a pill, a drink, or a toke—seems an eerie parallel. Moreover, it is certain that never before in human history has any nation so routinely medicated children and adolescents with a wide variety of incredibly powerful pharmaceuticals—all with little heed for the lifelong impacts on their cognitive functioning and overall health outcomes. No nation has ever been as entranced with mood-altering substances as America is today, and Big Pharma and Big Government seem to like it this way.

Of course, an ignorant and drugged nation, which naturally translates into a self-absorbed disregard for the needs of others, inevitably features a high level of basic cruelty—and in all three novels simple human compassion and connection is both dangerous and officially discouraged. In 1984 the two main characters are entrapped, arrested, and tortured for the anti-state crime of falling in love, and family connections are frayed by policies that treat emotions like bombs that need to be defused and discarded for (in that well-worn phrase of all totalitarians) the “greater good” of a society that is both sick and uncaring.

Unsurprisingly, miserable lives emptied of emotional connection lead to an epidemic of suicides in Fahrenheit 451 and the pitiable pursuit of soul-draining promiscuity in Brave New World (often aided by a hit of the ever-present Soma). Does this sound at all like the spiritual void of America today, where sexually-transmitted diseases and the millions of abortions that are the inevitable result of hit-and-run relationships that are less about commitment and caring and more about escaping loneliness by quickly exchanging some bodily fluids are a regular occurrence?

What all three of these dystopian novels agree upon is that powerful and omnipresent technology, to be used to eavesdrop, misinform, and control, is a necessary precursor to tyranny. We should be very, very worried by how much of our private information and thinking can today be made readily available to law enforcement, corporations, government agencies, marketers—and the generally nosey—with just a few taps on a computer screen

In only the past 50 years—a blink of the eye in relation to the past millennia or so—we have morphed from a disconnected and amazingly ignorant world filled with record players and desktop Rolodex card files to routine daily contacts with a global and all-powerful omni-brain that we carry around in our pockets. All the accumulated knowledge of the world and our collective history is now at our fingertips (no more pedaling your bicycle to the public library to look at the encyclopedia) while simultaneously and surreptitiously tracking our movements, recording our thoughts—and irreversibly rewiring our brains.

The imagined totalitarians and propagandists of Fahrenheit 451 (published in 1953), 1984 (published in 1949) and Brave New World (published in 1932) could not even begin to guess at the invasive technology that would keep us entertained with tomfoolery, titillate us with debasing pornography, bedazzle us with official lies and home brewed hatreds, and track us remorsefully and relentlessly throughout our lives. What a gift to today’s budding Hitlers, whether they are elected, appointed, or foisted upon us by some international body of brainwashed bureaucrats.

There is also, of course, the question of whether we are best enslaved with cruelty of comfort. Although a boot in the face has historically been the preferred method of totalitarian control, that might no longer be true. We seem happy to cooperate if plentiful drugs, streaming video, and unrestrained licentiousness are available. Why defy a dictatorship that massages our nerve endings?


Discover more from Common Sense

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Join the conversation